March 12, 2007

Gordon: lol
Rob: Strange part is that he made some really cool themes.
Gordon: He did - and speaking of music, it's time to list our Idols
Chico: Wee!
Gordon: It's time to play Who's Your Daddy and see who the Big Bad Daddy Idol is. We start with... Brandon Rogers
Chico: Good nucleus there.
Rob: Sure.
Don: Yep.
Gordon: Good voice, no personality to go with it. Staying in that same vein... Haley Scarnato
Rob: Above Brandon
Chico: Vibrato is the mind killer. Below Brandon
Don: After this past week, I'd say below Brandon.
Gordon: I'll agree with that, though I think Brandon is going first.

Brandon --> Haley

Chico: Unless someone completely falls out a la Melissa McGhee.
Gordon: Next up... Phil Stacey
Chico: Above Brandon
Rob: In the middle
Don: Above seems reasonable to me.
Gordon: I'll go with above Brandon as well. I think that he has a nice high range

Phil --> Brandon--> Haley

Gordon: Next... Stephanie Edwards
Chico: Copycat. Between Phil and Brandon
Don: Yeah.
Gordon: She needs her own identity, and she won't get it if she stays in R&B.
Below Phil.

Phil --> Stephanie --> Brandon--> Haley

Gordon: Here we go... Sanjaya Malakar
Don: I'd say between Brandon and Haley.
Chico: Below Haley...
Gordon: I'll have to go over Haley, but barely

Phil --> Stephanie --> Brandon--> Sanjaya ---> Haley

Gordon: Next one - Gina Glocksen
Chico: Above Phil
Rob: Definitely Above Phil.
Don: Easily.
Gordon: Agreed.

Gina -->Phil --> Stephanie --> Brandon--> Sanjaya ---> Haley

Gordon: Next? Chris Sligh
Chico: Below Gina.
Gordon: Good voice. Ok Personality. Midrange seems to be accurate

Gina --> Chris --> Phil --> Stephanie --> Brandon--> Sanjaya ---> Haley

Gordon: Annnndddd.... Jordin Sparks
Chico: ... I'm going to defer to the panel on this one, because I don't know what to make of her. Sure she's good for 17, but other than that, I don't know much about her.
Rob: I will put her above Stephanie
Don: Same here.
Chico: Then I will agree.
Gordon: I'll put her over Gina. She has the chops to win the whole thing

Gina -->Chris --> Jordin-->Phil --> Stephanie --> Brandon--> Sanjaya ---> Haley

Gordon: We got we got... Chris Richardson
Chico: Above Jordin. With the other Chris. Very versatile.
Rob: Yeah, Above Jordin as well.
Don: Sounds good to me.
Gordon: I agree. I think that he is good, but the presence of Blake hurts him

Gina -->Chris S. --> Chris R. -->Jordin-->Phil --> Stephanie --> Brandon--> Sanjaya ---> Haley

Gordon: Let's get this R&B powerhouse in here... LaKisha Jones.
Chico: Above Gina, but she better be careful
Rob: Below Chris R.
Don: I'd think at least above Chris S.
Gordon: I'll put her over Gina, but I think she needs to diversify
 
Gina -->LaKisha --> Chris S. --> Chris R. -->Jordin-->Phil --> Stephanie --> Brandon--> Sanjaya ---> Haley

Gordon: Beat Box time! Blake Lewis
Chico: Above Gina
Rob: Yeah, above Gina.
Don: Yeah.
Gordon: Ditto

Blake --> Gina -->LaKisha --> Chris S. --> Chris R. -->Jordin-->Phil --> Stephanie --> Brandon--> Sanjaya ---> Haley

Gordon: Final regular contestant... Melinda Doolittle
Chico: Above all.
Rob: She is my odds on favorite.
Don: Definitely.
Rob: Plus, The way Idol usually works means that a Woman will win this go-round. Since a guy won the last one.
Gordon: Uh...no.
Chico: It doesn't go girl-boy-girl-boy, =p
Rob: Didn't a guy win in 4?
Chico: Carrie Underwood's not a dude!
Gordon: Unless you know something about Carrie Underwood we don't know.
Rob: Oh, I'm confused then.
Gordon: Apparently.
Don: lol

Melinda --> Blake --> Gina -->Lakisha --> Chris S. --> Chris R. -->Jordin-->Phil --> Stephanie --> Brandon--> Sanjaya ---> Haley

Rob: I've been in college for way too long.
Gordon: Now we come to the Wild Cards. Fantasia Barrino
Rob: Winner of AI3 right?
Gordon: Yes
Rob: Below Chris R.
Chico: Between Richardson and Jordin, yeah
Don: Directly in the middle.
Gordon: I'll go under Chris R as well - so at least we don't think that this class is as weak as AI3

Melinda --> Blake --> Gina -->Lakisha --> Chris S. --> Chris R. -->Fantasia -->Jordin-->Phil --> Stephanie --> Brandon--> Sanjaya ---> Haley

Chico: But it does come dangerously close.. heh
Gordon: I think that you'll have much better talent than AI 3 when all is said and done.
Gordon: Last one... Angela Hacker
Rob: Who?
Chico: Nashville Star Champion. Below Gina. Let's see what happens when Angela rocks out.
Rob: Above the Two Chrises
Chico: Or gets some soul in her.
Don: Yeah, below Gina.
Gordon: I think she's good, but not as diverse, and that would hurt her.

Melinda --> Blake --> Gina -->Angela -->Lakisha --> Chris S. --> Chris R -->Fantasia -->Jordin-->Phil --> Stephanie --> Brandon--> Sanjaya ---> Haley

Gordon: So thats who we have
Chico: If you disagree, you know how to reach us. WLTI@gameshownewsnet.com.
Next up, the world-famous List Abuse. Stay there.

(Brought to you by The Search for the Next Snapple Lady. Join Wendy as she searches for her replacement. Hey, they have Pussycat Dolls, why not Snapple Ladies?)

CLICK HERE TO CONTINUE