We're in for another 3 months of praise, criticism
and endless bombardment of Ford and Coke commercials. I'll be bringing in my
usual friends from GameShowNewsnet.com to help in the proceedings, but for
today, here is a helpful (hopefully) American Idol primer from me.
Before
I start the primer though, it's time to get on the soapbox for a
second.
(Stands on Soapbox)
People of America. You
can't seem to make up your minds. You made fun of Idol because of Sanjaya. This
season, Idol sacrificed personality for music. These are the best 24 singers
that they have (or at least the top 20. We haven't heard 4 of them). Now you're
unhappy because Carly and others have had music contracts. A note to the
uninformed - over half of the Top 24 in almost EVERY season has had either
professional music experience or has had a previous contract. Even Season 1
winner Kelly Clarkson, before going on the show, had a music contract. So did Bo
Bice, Chris Daughtry, Taylor Hicks, and others. As Idol has said for years and
years; this is not a contest for the best new or amateur talent. It's not the
contest to find the biggest sob story. This is a contest to find the best
singer, period. Since Idol is in it's 7th season, it's taken the mainstream
media 6 years to figure this out?
If
you're complaining that people with more dynamic personalities didn't get in,
like Kyle Ensley or Josiah Leming, it's because you guys made such a stink about
Sanjaya that the judges replaced personality with talent. The change in format?
People wanted to make sure that the top 24 would be people who wouldn't crash
and burn under the spotlight. They removed the drama from the group auditions to
bring you a better product, and now you're complaining that the fun people
aren't there. Well it's your fault that you kept Sanjaya in the competition, so
now you pay the consequences for it.
Finally, for all of you who say 'well people shouldn't have another
chance, because they failed once'...so you're telling me that if you fail at one
thing in your profession, that you shouldn't try it again, and instead retire to
the white cliffs of DoveR&Become a bottlecap collector? Why don't you ask
the New York Football Giants if coach Tom Coughlin should have had a second
chance after going 19-29 in his last 3 years in Jacksonville, or ask the New
York Yankees if coach Joe Torre should have had a second shance after losing
more than 1,000 games in the National league. Why don't you ask Sean Combs if he
should have had a second chance for a musical career after a failure as a rap
artist the first time out. Why don't you ask Jerry Seinfeld if he should have
had a second season after the first season tanked. The 'well they failed once'
angle is the dumbest, most asinine argument I have ever
heard.
The
only thing that the 'media' who have come out with these 'breaking stories' has
shown is their own ignorance and lack of knowledge of American Idol. Now why
don't all of the people who are so quick to try to forecast the end of a
long-running show so they can be the first person to say 'I Told You So' either
actually DO RESEARCH before writing anything or just shut up and watch the show
so they would have enough knowledge of what they are covering to shove up a
flea's rear end.
Ok. I'm
done.
(Steps off Soapbox)
Now for the
primer...
The 12 Women
Joanne
Borgella
Where you've seen her: Idol: Best of the Rest (Feb 6)
with Knicks tickets from Madison Square Garden
Where else you may have seen her: She won
Mo'nique's 'Fat Chance', and appeared on many other shows
Why she's here: Her experience
from singing in Madison Square Garden was probably the edge that propelled her
over Cardin McKinney, who forgot her lyrics in a disastrous first round
Hollywood audition.
Pre-season Verdict: Right now
she's the third best R&B female singer behind Syesha Mercado and Asia'h
Epperson. That may not be good enough to make it to the Round of
12.
Kristy
Lee Cook
Where you've seen her: Idol: Philadelphia (Jan 15)
with her Cage Fighting outfit
Where else you may have seen her: She had an ill-fated
video in 2001, complete with Confederate Flag in the background. Why she's here: She's a cute
country voice. And she sings Amazing Grace very well.
Pre-season Verdict: Unfortunately, that's
the only thing she sings well, as she floundered during Hollywood. She reminds
me of David Brown in Idol 4, who got a lot of screen time, only to have 2 rotten
performances in the live show and get voted off. I can see an upset here if
Kristy can't get her act together - especially if Kady can take the country
genre from her.
Amy
Davis
Where you've seen her: WHO?
Where else you may have seen her: She was
in the Amy Davis Trio and Echoes of Pompei. She was also a contestant in
Nashville Star.
Why she's here: (Shrugs) The
judges liked her in Nashville Star?
Pre-season Verdict: She comes in advertised as a
country rocker chick. Only one problem - Amanda is also a rocker chick, and
she's gotten the face time. This spells trouble for Amy, who must produce
immediately, or she's gone in week #1.
Asia'h
Epperson
Where you've seen her: Idol: Atlanta (Feb 5) with a
few boxes of Kleenex
Where
else you may have seen her: Didn't get hit with the media ho
bug...yet...
Why she's
here: Backstory of her father dying before her audition plus a great
final song in The Round of 50.
Pre-season Verdict: She should
make the Top 12. She could finish in the Top 6, but she will have to outsing
Syesha Mercado to get any further than that.
Alexandrea Lushington
Where you've seen her: Idol: Atlanta (Feb 5) with her
great grandmother.
Where
else you may have seen her: She was one of the co-hosts in 'Lisa
Knight and the Round Table'. She was also on Star Search and lost to David
Archuleta.
Why she's here: She sang a better
'My Funny Valentine' than Constantine Maroulis did.
Pre-season Verdict: Grandmother should be
happy to see her get past week #1. If grandma has a weak heart, and if
Alexandrea doesn't outperform one of the other R&B singers, you may not want
granny to watch after said week.
Kady
Malloy
Where you've seen her: Idol: Dallas (January 16) with
all of her impressions.
Where else you may have seen her: Besides her
impressions, she does performances locally in Texas.
Why she's here: Simon likes her and said
that she would be his project. The last time he said that, it was to Carrie
Underwood, and we all know what happened there.
Pre-season Verdict: Simon is in
love with her - which means that during the Hollywood week, she probably got a
lot of attention from him. Keep in mind that the other people who Simon has
helped out have done extremely well on the show. If she can go into pop and
country, and if she can control her tone, she may be a dark horse to
watch.
Ramiele
Malubay
Where you've seen her: Idol: Miami (Jan 30) with her
Jasmine Trias autographed poster.
Where else you may have seen her: All over the
internet. There's apparently a website set up just to promote Ramiele all over
the cyberworld. And don't forget her tour in Florida.
Why she's here: She's a pint-sized
Jasmine Trias (Idol 3) with a voice.
Pre-season Verdict: If she continues to sing well and
stays cute in a Jasmine Trias way and not flip over to the precocious Michaela
Gordon / Vanessa Olivares dark side, she will probably attract the attention of
both Hawaii and Florida. If that happens, then she will go far - very far in the
competition. She could be a dark horse to win the whole
thing.
Syesha
Mercado
Where you've seen her: Idol: Miami (Jan 30) with a
video copy of her performances (all 2 of
them) in The One.
Where
else you may have seen her: The One, of course. She was also a member
of the Drum Studio All Stars.
Why she's here: Despite her cracking voice, she had a
great audition and an excellent final Hollywood Week song. One of only a handful
of people to have every audition aired.
Pre-season Verdict: Very, very
good. Not only does she have all of the statistics to go far (R&B, young
female, great backstory, memorable), but her televised appearances will go a
long way for handling the pressure of the competition. And yes, she can sing. My
preliminary last female standing and strong favorite to win the whole
thing.
Amanda
Overmyer
Where you've seen her: Idol: Atlanta (Feb 5) with her
Harley.
Where else you may
have seen her: Unless she did any reality hospital shows, nothing that
I can come up with.
Why she's here: She's a 23 year
old hard rocking Motorcycle Momma!
Pre-season Verdict: The sole female rocker should
easily make it to the Top 12. Then the problems begin. All we heard her sing is
rock songs. If she can't sing anything else (and with her gravelly voice, I'm
guessing she can't), then she will be an early finals
casualty.
Carly
Smithson
Where you've seen her: Idol: San Diego (January 22)
with her Irish accent and tattoos.
Where else you may have seen her: Maybe not as Carly
Smithson, but when she was Carly Hennessy, she released a forgettable single
called 'Let Me Blow Your Mind'...oh wait, I have that single. Oops. Working with
her on said album...Randy Jackson. Double Oops.
Why she's here: She's got a nice
voice, albeit slightly affected. And let's face it, if you had an album that
sold less than 500 copies, wouldn't you want to come back and redeem
yourself?
Pre-season Verdict: I don't know
if the controversy of her prior dealings will affect the voting. I think what
will affect the voting is that Americans don't like non-Americans winning their
titles. She should make the Top 12, but if she can't be diverse (and her voice
suggests that she can't), expect her to go sooner rather than
later.
Alaina
Whitaker
Where you've seen her: Idol: Dallas (January 16) with
a country twang.
Where
else you may have seen her: She has done performances with her high
school across Oklahoma. I don't think Randy Jackson or anyone in Idol were
scouting her out.
Why she's here: She's young. She's
cute. She's got a mellow raw voice...
Pre-season Verdict: ...which could get her in trouble
here with all of the heavyweights. Her audition was not mind-blowing, and the
competition is going to be steep. She better bring it early or she's going home
early.
Brooke
White
Where you've seen her: Idol: Philadelphia (Jan 15)
with her G Rated no smoking, no drinking persona.
Where else you may have seen her: She
opened for Phil Vassar in concert. Since she lives a G-rated persona, not
anywhere I've hung out :)P
Why she's here: She has a very old
fashioned voice, yet mature.
Pre-season Verdict: She's going to be competing
against Kristy Lee Cook and Kady Malloy for a country/rock slot. I don't think
she's going to get it.
The 12 Men
David Archuleta
Where you've seen him: Idol: San Diego (January 22)
with his paralyzed vocal chords and his check from Star
Search.
Where else you may have seen him:
He did win Star Search, knocking out a few former and current Idol hopefuls to
do it.
Why he's here: He not only has a
great voice, he has a great maturity about him - the maturity you would need to
win on a show like Star Search.
Pre-season Verdict: It's no secret
what Archuleta has done or achieved. He also will attract the kids votes and
he'll be under the radar while the others shine. This is the pattern of the
winners - plus he has the talent to back it up. Assuming that he doesn't get
caught in the backlash of people who have done other shows and have had other
contracts et al., he is going to be a strong favorite to win the whole thing.
Colton
Berry
Where you've seen him: Idol: Hollywood Round (February
12) with his Disney Renditions. He also has had quick cameos with him going nuts
with a yellow ticket.
Where else you may have seen him:
He does community church singing in Virginia.
Why he's here: The judges felt the love
tonight when he sang that song to them.
Pre-season Verdict: He got in over Kyle Ensley the
presidential candidate, who a lot of people liked. That could be problematic, as
could of his chances of getting to the Top 12 if he doesn't produce
immediately.
Robbie
Carrico
Where you've seen him: Idol: Miami (January 30) with
his old Britney Spears prom photos
Where else you may have seen him: Boyz and Girlz
United (formerly in that band) and Missing Picket (currently in that
band).
Why he's here: You have to have
some sort of Britney Spears influence on the show, don't you?
Pre-season Verdict: The fact that
he wasn't displayed at all during the Hollywood Round spells trouble. He does
have the look for a bottom half Top 12 finals appearance, or maybe higher than
that if he reminds us why he got picked to be in Boyz and Girlz United. If he
instead shows us why the band failed, then he will be on the outside of the Top
12 looking in and somewhere, Kyle Ensley will be throwing one of his campaign
pins at his television set.
Jason
Castro
Where you've seen him: WHO?
Where else you may have seen him: He was in
a band called Keeping Lions. He was also playing the main characters love
interest in the show Cheyenne
Why he's here: (Shrugs)...The
judges liked his dreds?
Pre-season Verdict: Enough people will know him in
Cheyenne (and dig the dreds) to survive week #1. That could give him enough time
to cultivate some listeners to get to the Top 12, but he has his work cut out
for him.
David
Cook
Where you've seen him: Idol: Omaha (January 29) with
hair that he stole from Christian from Project Runway 4.
Where else you
may have seen him:
If you've been in the Salt Lake area, he's been on tour there with the bands
Axium and MWK, as well as bartending in the local pub.
Why he's here: He added some
Daughtry on 'Living on a Prayer'. Also did some Bryan Adams and looks like he
could be the male soft rocker.
Pre-season Verdict: Boring. He has
flashes of very good in a sea of excellent. He could surprise and be another
Elliott Yamin, or he could wind up shaving his head in desperation to try to
convince the public that they have a second chance to keep Chris Daughtry alive
in the competition. I'll give him the benefit of the doubt and put him in the
Top 12, but he is quite vulnerable.
Chikezie Eze
Where you've seen him: Idol: Best of the Rest (Feb 6)
with his last season rejection certificate
Where else you may have seen him: American Idol last
year: he didn't qualify then, but he did now.
Why he's here: He's the only male R&B
singer left in the competition.
Pre-season Verdict: He reminds me a lot of Gedeon
McKinney - and not in a good way. That was during American Idol 5, when Gedeon
was the male R&B singer, but because the ladies sang circles around him,
didn't have enough votes to get into the Top 12. Unless he steps up his game, I
see history repeating itself here, with Chikeze departing exactly where Gedeon
did - right outside the Top 12 looking in. I'll put him in for now, but that's a
very, very shaky call.
Garrett
Haley
Where you've seen him: WHO?
Where else you may have seen him: He
performed in Elida High School in Elida, Ohio.
Why he's here: (Shrugs)...He makes the
judges pine for Leif Garrett?
Pre-season Verdict: Unknown kid? Check. Young? Check.
Must produce or he's out the door in week 1? Check.
David Hernandez
Where you've seen him: Idol: Hollywood Round (February
12) with a lot of love...or something like that.
Where else you may have seen him: He was a
member of the bands Tribet and Straight Up. He also was a part of Arizona Idol.
The person who won Arizona Idol last year? Jordin Sparks.
Why he's here: The judges loved
him. Me? Ehhh...
Pre-season Verdict: He's got an affected voice that
could have issues when put in a stressing situation. He may be going against
Danny Noriega for both the pop vote and the cute vote, and Noriega has the edge.
If he gets in the Top 12, it's barely.
Michael
Johns
Where you've seen him: Idol: San Diego (January 22)
with his Australian accent.
Where else you may have seen him: Where haven't you
seen him? He was in the bands The Rising and Film. Not to mention that Idol has
been pimping him out on every single audition song as many chances as they can
get.
Why he's here: As American Idol
has shown you every chance they get, he's got a great smooth voice. And the
pouty look won't hurt either.
Pre-season Verdict: Idol and the
Oddsmakers are making him the favorite in the competition. What happens to the
favorite? They don't win. No favorite has EVER won American Idol. In addition,
the backlash from many sites (not to mention the fact that he's not an American)
will go against him, regardless of his talent. He'll make the Top 12, but he
also won't go as far as people think he will, and I sense he will be the major
upset as person going home quicker than expected.
Luke
Menard
Where you've seen him: WHO?
Where else you may have seen him: He was in
a group called Chapter 6.
Why he's here: (Shrugs)...The judges heard Chapter
6?
Pre-season
Verdict: With no face time at all, this has 'Week one Bootee' written
all over him. If he doesn't sing well, he's gone.
Danny
Noriega
Where you've seen him: Idol: Best of the Rest (Feb 6)
with his Sanjaya photo album
Where else you may have seen him: American Idol last
year: he didn't qualify then, but he did now.
Why he's here: Looks and a surprisingly
good 'When I Need You' in the Hollywood Round.
Pre-season Verdict: He will either channel
up the Clay Aiken crowd with his big voice out of a small body, or the Sanjaya
Crowd with his personality - especially if he falters early. Regardless of what
group he falls into, he has a legitimate shot to make the Top 12 and will go
further than what most people will give him credit for.
Jason
Yeager
Where you've seen him: WHO?
Where else you may have seen him: He was in
Making the Band...but he didn't make the band
Why he's here: (Shrugs)...Puffy and Paula
were having backstage talks?
Pre-season Verdict: Like some others, his fame will
keep him around through week #1. He has the potential to get past week #2, but
we would have to see a part of him that we didn't see in Making the Band - the
talent part.
Haterade's Pre-Season Predictions:
Top 12
Joanne Borgella
Asia'h Epperson
Kady Malloy
Ramiele
Malubay
Syesha
Mercado
Amanda
Overmyer
Carly
Smithson
David Archuleta
David Cook
Chikeze Eze
David Hernandez
Michael
Johns
Danny
Noriega
Top 6
Asia'h
Epperson
Kady
Malloy
Ramiele
Malubay
Syesha
Mercado
David Archuleta
Michael Johns
Top
2
Syesha Mercado
David Archuleta
Winner
David Archuleta
So those are my picks. We'll see very soon how they pan out.
See you in 7.