"Round of 3:
Judge's Choice" - May 17-19
This week, we have a bonus!
Remember that we didn't have a World Idol competition
this year? Well, after the following hour of television,
you may know why.
Now we all know how big
American Idol has grown for the last four years. Judges
are famous, winners are famous, losers are infamous...
But forget about the Kelly Clarksons, the Ruben
Studdards, the Fantasias, the Bo Bices... okay, so I'm
getting ahead of myself. Instead, let's talk about the
Leroys, the Mary Roaches, the William Hungs and other
assorted characters as we present for your viewing
pleasure... "American Idol: The World's Worst
Auditions."
History: FremantleMedia's
Idols format is a hit in 31 countries, meaning that for
every Simon Cowell, there's an Ian "Dicko" Dickson
(British transplant on "Australian Idol"), and for every
"Like a Virgin" Keith or William Hung, there's a cloggin'
Klaus ("Idols") and a Michael Chan ("Australian Idol").
Okay, so that last one was pretty much a full circle
thing.
Today, we look inside
"American Idol", "Idols", "Superstar", "Superstar KZ",
"Deutschland Sucht Den Superstar", "Canadian Idol", "ldolos",
"Australian Idol", "A la Recherce de la Nouvelle Star"..
and of course "Pop Idol" for the best of the worst from
round the globe. Each of tonight's performers bring one
common bond to the table... They suck. Hard.
First, we go to the UK, and
the beginning... ITV's "Pop Idol 2001". If only for a
montage of tempers, tears, and Will Young. That leads us
to a trip through Russia, Belgium, the Netherlands, the
Pan Arab nations, and Kazakhstan.
EP Ken Warwick: "The
mistakes are common across the board. The people try to
overdo the entrance, and of course, it never works."
True that, we have the Belgian robot, the Pole jig (and
I don't know what Polish judge Kuba Wodzjewowski said
just then, but it can't be good), the Kazakh dude who
forgot the lyrics... yeah, you'll be leaving now. But
surely the good folks up in Canada have a bit of mercy.
After all, this is the country that gave the world Ryan
Vickers. ... See? Where else will you have a panel of
judges help a guy who forgot the lyrics?
And the one thing that
NEVER works: a bribe. Hats, flowers, posters, t-shirts
that say "Big girls rock". In Poland is where they get
creative. Anyone care for a prehistoric jaw?
And the kiss of death: the
age limit. Here in America, you can be as old as 28
(which means I still have two more Idol lines in me),
but some people.. just don't get it. EP Nigel Lythgoe:
"It always amazes me that when people come into the
audition room and lie about their age. It's pretty
obvious that they're over the age limit." Cue Joseph
Bland from earlier this season, and Brendan from
Northern Ireland... with a medley of songs people love
to hate, a voice that EVERYONE loves to hate, and a
mullet that he hates himself.
Season two's "Against All
Odds" returns us to the US for a bit of fuel, right
before we get to... screeching. Queen banshee: Jennifer
Amaro from Chicago. She was an Idol-wannabe from season
1, back when we literally had... nothing. Jennifer
proves that point. Simon puts her in her place: "That
was extraordinary. Extraordinarily BAD!"
Mere child's play
compared... to Dicko. "I can think of a perfect place
for you to perform. The Nullarbor. It's a big expanse of
nothingness where no one can hear you." Nigel: "The
Brits have got a good sense of humor when they're
delivering a barbed comment. They deliver it with
humor." Example: "We talk about the X-factor. You just
created the Y-factor, 'cause I sat here and thought,
'Why the hell... did you bother showing up today'."
Another
Brit-by-virtue-of-the-fact-that-the-Queen-is-on-their-money
delivering a barbed comment: Canada's Zack Werner. "For
the first time I kinda understand what childbirth must
feel like. Because watching you go through that has to
be one of the most painful experiences anyone can go
through."
The Polish Simon: "You look
like a stuffed bird." The Polish Paula... is OLD.
The Kiwi Paula (Kiwi = native of New Zealand) on "NZ
Idol": "You can't actually sing in tune." That was so
passive, it past right by me and I didn't even notice.
The Australian Paula: "Sounds like you gargle with
razorblades." The Canadian Waterman (Jake Gold):
"*burble* What was that?" And the bullets begin
a-flying. World War III will be fought in the audition
room. One side: the judges. The other... the contestants
who actually fight back, as this lady from Canada does,
asking the judges what exactly good singing is.
And then there's Tammica...
"That's Ta-MI-ka!" Okay Tamika, she has it out with all
three AI judges. And then to the cameraman outside. You
remember, British asses kissing hers... Paula's just
jealous? Yeah, that. then you have the tearjerks, as
Pete Waterman of "Pop Idol" illustrates to a Westlife
clone. Then there's the Norwegian superhero and the
tight-face from Germany with the air-guitar.
Dino Yazzie from season 2
kicks off "dudes and divas", where a guy will sing a
girl's song. Rather horridly. Randy: "You ever been on a
farm? Sheep tryin' to sing?" (bleats)
Elvis, Rick Astley, and
nerds all coming up shortly. Yep, it's all about dancing
from Germany to Canada and all points in between. The
final verdict: "Please pass out."
Nigel is amazed at how many
people imitate Elvis. In America... In New Zealand.. In
Germany... In Kazakhstan... In Portugal.. In
Australia... and in one guy in Norway. In some guy
in Poland. And in some Willie Nelson impersonator in the
UK. Ouch. Elvis gets around. Get'em, Pete! "I
don't think this job's for you. How the hell can you do
Elvis Presley like that."
We're at the "what not to
wear" portion of the show, as we have the crossdresser,
the wizard, the cowgirl pimp, a dragon (?), a cat, a
bear, and Dorothy. Nigel puts it like this: "There's a
correlation between what you wear and how much talent
you have. The least talent, the least amount of clothes
you wear." In short: compensation. Example: Gigi from
Australia. No voice plus big whammies plus tight-fitting
shirt even by Australian standards equals... "No one is
ever going to get tired of taking photographs of you,
but no one is ever going to want to listen to you."
Then comes a second-season
contestant with the longest version of "Unchained
Melody" ever... I can measure the years passing by as
she is singing.
And then comes Keith, as
he's talking to then-contestant-come-co-host Kristin
Holt (who can now be seen hosting G4's "Cheat!".. Good
that she's still working). Keith on the other hand...
can be seen... well, somewhere... dancing... horribly.
Scarily.
Then there are the freaks.
One freak in particular is a bloke in England who claims
the title of world's biggest Idols fan. Sorry, Gordon.
He knows about the £5 million home in Holland Park
(that's common knowledge) and what Pete Waterman was
doing with Nicki Chapman last night (that... isn't).
Unfortunately, he doesn't know a lick about singing. As
doesn't this Dutch guy, who's so bad, he's actually
bleeped.
And now, because you hung
around this long.. NERDS! We relive Adam & Dirk. We
relive Derek from season 1. We live (for the first time
in America) Warren, who believes that he is the next
"Pop Idol". Sounds like Sly doing "Eye of The Tiger".
Cue nerd montage. Of course, we couldn't have a nerd
montage without... William Hung. But he is put to shame
by Chris in the UK. He calculates his odds as 1 in
500... Simon puts it right, though, "How come the odds
are a million to one?"
From the truly bad, we look
forward to the truly terrific. Carrie and Bo next week.
One of them is the next American Idol. Tune in to see
which one it is.
|