"Round of 7: 70s Dance
Music" - April 19-20
It's Tuesday, April 19.
Thirty-five million sets of eyes are on one focal
point... Ryan's hair. And after that, we have seven
singers waiting for your vote to keep them alive as we
move closer to crowning the next American Idol.
This week... it's all
about the 70s dance music. So dictates the theme. Now
here's what I don't get. Why not just call it disco?
Hell, we even have a disco ball!
Are we in for the most
energetic week ever? Well, let's get it on! First up,
Constantine Maroulis. He covers "Nights on Broadway" by
the Bee Gees. He says he thinks about glam and
finger-pointing when it comes to the 70s.
What they say: Randy
liked the song choice, but called the overall package a
Las Vegas performance. "It was alright, but it wasn't
like, oh my God!" Paula begs to differ. No, literally,
she does. "You have a habit of picking the right songs,
mix it with theatrics. You've got stage presence. You're
going to be selling lots of records." Simon calls on
Constantine's roll, but likens the performance to a
waiter in a Spanish/Vegas nightclub playing performer.
What we say: I don't
know what Randy and Simon are talking about. That was a
genuine Constantine performance right there with a good
song choice. But I would lose the lounge lizard duds.
That's career suicide. And a nice tit-for-tat with the
band. You know, when you play on the band like that, it
makes you sound better. When you just play off the
band... well, you take your chances.
Good start to the show,
but we roll on to Carrie Underwood, who thought, after
hearing the theme, "Oh man, I'm in trouble. A) I don't
know that much about 70s dance music and b) we really
don't have that many nightclubs in Checotah, Oklahoma."
Get into trouble with "Macarthur Park" by Donna Summer.
What they say: Randy
officially welcomes Carrie into the Dawg Pound, saying
that she's one of the best singers in the competition.
Paula calls Carrie on a note that shook the heavens.
Simon likes the song, but has issue with this week's
look: "Barbie meets the Stepford Wives."
What we say: You may not
have noticed it, but Carrie flubbed a lyric again
("Macarthur's Park"), and her hairstylist needs to be
fired. I defer the rest of the time on this contestant
to my sister, Quisla.
What Q says: Everything
about that performance was horrible.
Not to be confused with
the Gloria Estefan version of "Everlasting Love", but we
get the Carl Carlton best version (Gloria's a close
second) courtesy of Scott Savol, who says that "the 70s
ain't his thang."
What they say: Randy is
impressed by his song choice. "It was hot." Paula "gives
Scotty his props." Simon ... after a brain lapse,
finally figures out why Scott is still here. "You are
ordinary guy doing quite well. At the same time,
ordinary guys can get up at the karaoke bar and sort-of
entertain an audience."
What we say: It's
uniquely Scott. It's weak to start, strong to finish,
and somewhere in the happy medium... in the happy
medium. But give Scott props for having fun on stage.
But the whole song is marred by miscues on pitch. But
that's the only problem. Too bad it's a big and
consistent one. Oh yeah, and he talks too much.
Proving that any Joe
Schmuck worth his dime in Hollywood can get tickets,
Alex Trebek in the audience... looking rather dapper.
The answer: "This singer will be this year's American
Idol." Who? "I only give the answer." Yeah. We'll find
out the question in a month. Right now, another thing
big in the 70s (aside from Alex's fro/manperm) was
"Don't Take Away the Music". Then, the Tavares. Now,
Anthony Fedorov. He took Latin dance for a few years,
which does explain the new geeky white boy hotness the
girls think he has.
What they say: Randy
says, "Everyone says 'Oh man, this might be the week
Anthony falls down.' He didn't do it this week!" Paula
calls the song choice "soothing." Simon places it
amongst the best weeks with a backhanded compliment: "It
was pleasant, safe, and a little insipid."
What we say: Still a
shade off of perfection pitchwise, but... best...
Anthony performance... ever. He needed something like
that to keep him in the contest. If he turns out stuff
like this, then MAYBE he could be a contender.
MAYBE.
Odds are, oh, one in
750. Reminder: benefit single from the Idols is in store
now... BUY! Vonzell Solomon is every woman. Certainly MY
woman :). She goes for Chaka Khan in "I'm Every Woman."
What they say: Randy
says Vonzell chose a song with a high degree of
difficulty, but worked it out. Paula says she rocked.
Simon agrees with Randy. "Your personality can carry a
song like that."
What we say: What
Whitney Houston broke, Vonzell fixed. The tone was right
where it needed to be, and she commanded the stage.
Although the background singers need to remember that...
they're background singers. I'm trying to hear my girl
here!
Next on the disco parade
is Anwar Robinson, choosing "September". "The fashion
was off the hook." I'll tell you right now. I LOVE Earth
Wind & Fire. THAT better be off the hook.
What they say: Randy
calls it good, pitchy to start, strong to finish. Paula
calls it awesome. Simon doesn't think it was THAT good,
not a winning performance.
What we say: Back to
classic Anwar. Not a good thing. He only half-sings the
song, holding back on the most important parts (that
would be, oh, beginning, middle, and end), and... and I
CAN'T stress this enough. If you are going to sing Earth
Wind & Fire, you HAVE to pull off the falsetto. Anything
less is a D, as Quentin Tarantino said.
And your band did it?
Hopefully you weren't singing. Well, we've reached last
call with Bo Bice, who chose "Vehicle" by the Ides of
March. He never got the dance thing. And he's not much
of a dancer, but he likes to get everyone up to dance.
What they say: Randy
says "Bo Bice is definitely back." He can hear that
being recorded. Paula: "Competition is back on." She got
chills. Simon calls it authentically good.
What we say: I agree
with Simon 100 percent. That was authentic Bo and I
loved every minute of it.
Competition is
definitely on. There wasn't a single-worst performance
in the night, and Ryan makes sure everyone knows it...
but for purposes of comparison...
Disco Inferno: Vonzell,
Constantine, Bo
Disco Sucks: Carrie, Anthony, Anwar
Scott Savol: Scott
This charting was hard.
Sure, they were all good, but still, one person has to
go home. Sorry, folks. That's just the rules. If you
want to win, you have to survive the public vote. One
person will not. Randy thinks Simon's going home. Paula
doesn't play politics. Simon says, based on a miserable
performance... Ryan should go home. We'll see if Simon's
right in 24.
I doubt he is, though.
CLICK HERE TO CONTINUE |