|
"The Great Debate" - July
11
With only one week
remaining before the big showdown, all of the scholars
are on edge. That is, all of the scholars except for
Melissa, Scot, Milana and Liz who have all secured their
position in the final. Lets take a look at the
prospects of the remaining scholars getting into the
final.
Alyssa- She has not earned her way into an admissions
showdown yet, and often has a problem wearing her
emotions on her sleeve. If she pulls herself together it
is hard to believe that she wont be given a shot out of
pity.
Amari- Amari has been in the Admissions showdown twice,
both times receiving the bye from the admission
committee. While she has not proven herself to be the
strongest leader, Amari has time and again proved
herself to be an excellent contributor.
Davis- Clearly the cockiest of all of the competitors he
is also one of the sharpest. His abrasive personality
has kept him out of the favor of the admission
committee, but his competitive edge has led him to the
Admissions Showdown as a leader twice, giving him the
best rack record to make this third time his charm.
Gerald- Although he is a varsity mascot, Gerald has
allowed himself to fall into mild obscurity. Yet, his
noble presence has never been the source of adversity
and amongst other more vocal personalities, his
simplicity may have the chance to shine.
Jeremy- Being potentially the most emotionally invested
contestant has allowed Jeremy to be viewed by the
admission committee as being the most honorable
contestant, yet his honor may force him to fall on his
own sword when it counts.
Max- The self-proclaimed ladies man has moved his game
from the ladies to his studies. Yet, he has not achieved
any particularly impressive results in any given
challenge. With a weaker track record, an improved
performance may be more easily detected by the
admissions committee.
So now that you have an idea of the positions that the
remaining contestants are in let head to the captains
quiz.
Captains Quiz
As a first, the four contestants who have already won a
place in the finals are asked to step aside so that only
those students to whom the win matters most will
compete. The remaining six are asked t complete a
matching quiz consisting of quotes from the bill of
rights.
As ahs become somewhat cliché, Davis is overly confident
and is sure that he is going to win a position as
captain because he knows more about the constitution
than any of the other scholars. While other times, Davis
has fallen, (see: Margaret Mitchell) this time he turned
in a perfect score, and will be one of the captains.
Joining him, in somewhat of a surprise, is Amari who got
8 correct in the fastest time.
Now it is time for the first ever (
and probably last
ever) Scholar Field trip!
As the scholars are taken on a tour of the Reagan
library, everyone is impressed with the presidential
stature and allure they are surrounded by. Davis
reiterates his goal of becoming president and more
importantly points out that if his team doe not win this
challenge that he is probably done for. Thus a lot of
weight falls on what the challenge will be and the team
selections that are made right now.
|
Max,
Davis, Melissa |
|
Amari,
Alyssa, Jeremy |
Team Challenge
All of the skills of a reality show contestant are going
to be put to the test as the scholars will have to
bicker and argue in a genuine debate. The Topic,
Legalization of gay marriage, and the Gold team has been
assigned PRO while the red team will be covering CON.
With one hour to prepare and the resources of the
library at their fingertips the scholars have their work
cut out for them. They will be judged by Gordon Stables,
the USC debate coach, and Tim Biblarz, a professor of
Sociology.
Im not even going to waste time recapping their
preparation. Both teams worked well together, Davis
team was very confident and Amaris team was freaking
about having to defend a position that was against ever
fiber in their body (at least as Jeremy put it).
Its debate time and while you maybe be hoping to hear
some kind of revolutionary argument that you have never
heard before for the talented youth of our nation, this
time that is not going to happen. The Gold team praises
the need for equal rights for minority groups and
establishes that homosexuals as a minority group should
be given the same protections and privileges afforded to
all other citizens. The Red team rebuts stating that
Marriage is a religious institution that celebrates the
sanctity of a relationship between man and woman and
using the constitution to change that would be denying
the moral fabric that the constitution itself was
created from. Yes, folks this issue is apparently that
black and white. So, black and white that a slate at the
commercial break stated the views expressed on The
Scholar do not represent the views of the Ronald Reagan
Presidential Library. This one-second blip was one of
the highlights of the episode for me.
Now for the decision. While all of the scholars were
very skilled at bringing across their respective points,
both the judges agreed that the Gold team did a better
job giving them the win, and Davis his third earned slot
in the Admissions Showdown. Everyone else will have to
wait for the list.
After the cursory round of interviews, the list is
posted, and no ones name is on it. Instead a message
notifies all of the scholars not yet in the finals to
study the topic of American presidents. So with everyone
in panic mode, everyone is worried that Davis is a shoe
in due to his all-expansive history knowledge (who is
this kid, Ken Jennings?). Regardless, after hours of
studying, three of these kids will be left out in the
cold with nothing but video memories of their sad
failure on the Scholar (and about 50 scholarships being
offered from schools viewing the show).
Whos in, whos out? Joining Davis will be Amari and
Alyssa. This crushes Jeremy, who fights his hardest to
hold back the tears welling up in his eyes. Tears aside,
congratulations to all of the Scholars who have competed
on this show win or lose as they are trying their best
to succeed in the realm of academia, a noble pursuit in
todays society.
Admissions Showdown
Game on.
Amari- 3rd President Jefferson
Davis- 5th President Monroe
Alyssa- 7th President Jackson
Amari- 1st V.P, Adams
Yada, yada, yada
The scholars do fine in the
memorization test, but begin to falter on the harder
questions.
Setting the drama:
What 2 presidents were assassinated in the 20th Century?
Almost instantly, the answers of Lincoln and Garfield
are given. Now at first glance, the answers may appear
to be correct, but in hindsight, you might realize
Lincoln was president in the 1800s and therefore was
assassinated in the 19th century whereas the question
refers to the 20th. Now this might just be viewed as a
simple mistake, yet this mistake was made by Davis,
eliminating him from all contention on The Scholar.
Worse yet, Rob Nelson forced him to confirm his answer a
la millionaire. Davis swears that he heard 19th century,
but unfortunately that doesnt matter. (Correct Answers:
Kennedy, McKinley)
That leaves Amari and Alyssa and Alyssa is up next.
What president won a Nobel peace prize in 1906 for his
work during the Russo-Japanese war? Now, this is a
situation where the Jeopardy rule can bite you in the
bottom. Alyssa knew it was a Roosevelt but she wasnt
sure which one. Instead of trying to sneak Roosevelt
trough as an answer she added Franklin and paid the
price. Teddy would have gotten her through one more
round, but if she had just said Roosevelt, who knows,
maybe she would have gotten away with it?
That makes is match point Amari. Here is the question
What President was sworn in in 1923 by his father?
Working methodically through the years, Amari came to
the answer of Coolidge
and walked away with $50,000.
So the field is set. Melissa, Scot, Milana, Liz and
Amari will be battling it out head to head for the full
ride $240,000 scholarship. Dont feel bad for Alyssa,
Davis, Gerald, Max, and Jeremy though. In addition to
all of the other prizes they have won, all the scholars
were awarded the Intel Centrino computers they have been
working with all series. So until next week, put your
thinking caps on and prepare for the ultimate brawl of
the brains. |