Remember, one of the guys is straight, available, and interested. Another is spoken for by another female. Another still is gay and taken by another male. As evidenced by two phone calls. And if you pick either one of them... they're going on YOUR vacation.

First impressions from Kara...

GAY: Ryan
STRAIGHT: Nick
TAKEN: Robert

First up, ballet. Kara's looking for someone who's a little bit goofy. Nick... his ass hurts. He seemed comfortable with the instructor, grabbing him by the... twig and berries. Robert and Kara have a bit of a connection, while the other guys "check each other out." After all that...

GAY: Nick
STRAIGHT: Ryan
TAKEN: Robert

Nick handles a gun next. He grew up hunting as a kid. And no, Nick, you hit nothing with that crossbow. He blinds Kara and, in an exercise of trust, takes the safety off the crossbow she's holding. And... bullseye.

Robert gets to handle pottery. So he handled pottery and he's taken ballet classes... and has four older sisters. After that...

GAY: Robert
STRAIGHT: Ryan
TAKEN: Nick

Ryan goes two-stepping. He likes kids and just got off of a five-year relationship.

Today, Kara gets to inspect toiletry bags. Nick has a pretty simple bag. Ryan... has a microtouch, and apparently he uses it everywhere. Robert has chocolate body wash. And a manicure/pedicure kit.

It's decision time. With the significant others in tow, here are Kara's final picks...

GAY: Ryan
STRAIGHT: Robert
TAKEN: Nick

Nick is... gay. Robert... is taken. Sorry, Kara, but Rob and that girl over there are going on a vacation to Mexico.

Episode #2 features Marisa, a 29-year-old waitress who likes paintball, karate, and aerobics. She's looking for a chiseled cook basically. Tony (33, immigration lawyer), Yaacov (personal trainer), and Ezra (26, real estate investor) all swear they're the one for her. For only one, that is actually true.

Yaacov's from Israel, while Tony is a military brat. They spend the great part of their time bickering, while Ezra is focused on her.

After the calls... "This is gonna be a long day." Let's compare drinks. Tony: Tokyo tea. Ezra: Hennessy and Coke. Yaacov... apple martini. First impressions...

GAY: Yaacov
STRAIGHT: Ezra
TAKEN: Tony

First up, foot massages all around with Marisa and Ezra. Ezra tells Marisa that his last girlfriend was flown to Jamaica for a birthday. Then the manicurists come in, wondering if Ezra's the gay one... in their native tongue.

Tony and Marisa get their jiujutsu on next. And after being tackled, Tony grabs him a little something something. And another foot massage. And Tony's feet? Yeowch. One word... Boom, tough actin' Tinactin. Tony shows her his kanji tattoos. All 11 of them. And three piercings. Two on his eyebrow and one on his chin. After that...

GAY: Tony
STRAIGHT: Ezra
TAKEN: Yaacov

Yaacov goes tap-dancing. He's taken jazz as a kid. Good for him. After that...

GAY: Yaacov
STRAIGHT: Tony
TAKEN: Ezra

Slide show! Yaacov's got the Milli Vanilli and the matching wifebeaters with his friend. Tony has the Gumby and the chin ring. Ezra cooks and wears a speedo.

Decision time. Which means... time for the others. Final decision...

GAY: Tony
STRAIGHT: Ezra
TAKEN: Yaacov

Tony... is indeed gay. And Ezra... jackpot. He and Marisa are going to Nuevo Vallarta.