American Idol Season 5 Scorecard -- Preliminary Rounds

GSNN InSites

February 21 - 23, 2006

denotes InSites' pick for elimination

GIRLS -- Tuesday (2/21/06)

Order

Name

Song Choice

Randy

Paula

Simon

Wk1 Rank

Overall

VoteResult

5

Paris Bennett

"Midnight Train to Georgia"

++

++

++

3

3

Safe

4

Ayla Brown

"Reflection"

+

+

+

5

5

Safe

8

Heather Cox

"When You Tell Me That You…"

x

x

x

10

10

Safe

7

Brenna Gethers

"You Are the Sunshine of My Life"

-

+

x

9

9

Safe

1

Mandisa Hundley

"Never"

+

+

+

4

4

Safe

9

Melissa McGhee

"When the Lights Go Down"

-

++

+

6

6

Safe

12

Katharine McPhee

"Since I Fell For You"

++

++

+++

2

2

Safe

3

Becky O'Donohue

"Because the Night"

+

x

-

11

11

12th

2

Kellie Pickler

"How Far"

-

-

+

8

8

Safe

6

Stevie Scott

"To Where You Are"

x

+

x

12

12

11th

11

Kinnik Sky

"Get Here"

-

+

-

7

7

Safe

10

Lisa Tucker

"I Am Changing"

+

++

++

1

1

Safe

GUYS -- Wednesday (2/22/06)

Order

Name

Song Choice

Randy

Paula

Simon

Wk1 Rank

Overall

VoteResult

10

Bobby Bennett

"Copa Cabana"

-

-

x

10

10

12th

7

Kevin Covais

"One Last Cry"

++

++

x

4

4

Safe

3

Bucky Covington

"Simple Man"

+

-

-

9

9

Safe

6

Chris Daughtry

"Wanted Dead or Alive"

++

++

++

3

3

Safe

1

Patrick Hall

"Come To My Window"

+

-

x

11

11

11th

12

Taylor Hicks

"Levon"

+

+

+

6

6

Safe

4

Will Makar

"I Want You Back"

+

+

-

8

8

Safe

8

Gedeon McKinney

"Shout"

+

++

x

7

7

Safe

2

David Radford

"A Crazy Little Thing Called Love"

x

-

x

12

12

Safe

5

Sway Penala

"Reasons"

++

++

x

5

5

Safe

9

Elliott Yamin

"If You Really Love Me"

+++

++

+++

1

1

Safe

11

Ace Young

"Father Figure"

+++

+++

++

2

2

Safe